When I was editing some night city shots RAW files that have a couple light signs in it that are overblown, when pulling highlights down, I can get quite a bit more out of the same image in Photoshop. I do not own PS myself but have tried it on a friends Mac. We just opened the image and didn't do anything else than pull the highlights down to see if there is a difference.
In PS one can get a better image out of it. When going down 90 or 100% on the highlights slider, the effect is quite a bit stronger on PS. In Photomator it is not possible to get the highlights down as in PS. Probably the same with shadows but I have not compared it.
Wondering if this is something that will be further improved in Photomator. As far as I remember there was an update last year that said it improved shadow and highlight recovery significantly. But looks like it is not quite on the level of PS.
Highlights recovery not as good as Adobe still
2023-11-03 15:01:05
2023-11-03 16:16:01
In Photomator try holding the option key it doubles the slider range.
2023-11-04 10:08:29
I can see that option key affects some sliders such as exposure or brightness as you say.
But it does not affect all sliders and also on highlights slider I can see no change and no added latitude.
Some other sliders like clearity or texture also do not seem to be affected by the option key.
2023-11-06 14:27:56
I also occasionally have trouble pulling as much texture out of light areas compared to what I've been able to do using another product (Darkroom, in my case).
This isn't a perfect comparison for a number of reasons, but here's part of a photo with a cloudy sky. In Photomator it's mostly an indistinct gray:
In Darkroom, the clouds have much more texture throughout. This is a result I've struggled to recreate in Photomator:
This isn't a perfect comparison for a number of reasons, but here's part of a photo with a cloudy sky. In Photomator it's mostly an indistinct gray:
In Darkroom, the clouds have much more texture throughout. This is a result I've struggled to recreate in Photomator:
2023-11-29 09:13:16
I have the same problem with Photomator
2023-12-05 16:42:51
Might be worth filling in the contact form to ask the pixelmator team if this is a known issue they are looking at or if not if they maybe could?